Good practices of initiative:
ESP: DECOFOS: Proyecto de Desarrollo Comunitario Forestal de los Estados del Sur - México
Relevance
It measures the alignment of the initiative with existing policy frameworks in the country. In addition, the scalability of the initiative to other realities and geographies is valued.
| Marco | Description | Ambit | Country | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IFADs Strategic Framework | Global | World (aggregate) | Link | |
| National Hunger Crusade | National | Mexico | Link |
Eficacy
This measures how well the objectives and goals set out in the initiative were fulfilled, as well as the extent to which the results achieved are attributable to the actions implemented by the initiative.
| Indicator | Description | Indicator Type | Measure Unit | Base date | Base | Goal | Measure Date | Measure | Compliance | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Index | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.017 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Precipitation seasonality (coefficient of variation) | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Coefficient of variation | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.376 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households affected by climate impacts since 2011 | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.171 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households affected by the drought | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 6.203 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Permit requirement to exploit communal lands by households | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -7.491 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | ||||
| Total Gross Household Income | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | USD | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 7.329 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Income diversification (Number of income sources) | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Number | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 227.762 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Durable Assets Index | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Index | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 243.422 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Index of productive assets | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Index | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.092 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Total Assets Index | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Index | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.004 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households below the asset-based poverty line, 40th percentile | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.106 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households below the asset-based poverty line, 60th percentile | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.029 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households that exploit the natural resources of communal lands | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -1.16 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Income from the sale of natural resources from communal lands | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | USD | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -4.144 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Income from the sale of tree resources | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | USD | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 6.538 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Home Operated Parcels | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Number | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 21.185 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Activities of sale of communal land products | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 3.492 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households that started new businesses since 2011 | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.199 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Net profit from commercial activities | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | USD | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.013 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Net income from crop sales | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | USD | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.022 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Gini-Simpson index of crop diversification | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Index | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 78.113 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Adult Food Insecurity Experience Scale Score | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -37.474 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | ||||
| Children Food Insecurity Experience Scale Score | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.044 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | ||||
| Number of meals consumed per day by the household | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Number | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -0.200 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households with activities selling products to final consumers | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -0.05 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households that buy seeds and other agricultural inputs from family and friends | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -0.143 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Women group in the community | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.068 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | ||||
| Participation in farmer groups since 2011 (yes=1) | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 5.087 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | ||||
| Participation in women groups since 2011 (yes=1) | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 1.262 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | ||||
| Groups in which households participate since 2011 | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Number | 19-07-2022 | 19-07-2022 | -0.802 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Households with members with leadership positions in farmer groups | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en los beneficiarios | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 3.137 | Impact evaluation- Treatment Group | |||
| Difference between the percentage change between average agricultural or livestock yields per hectare between beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries | Impact | Percentage | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.045 | |||||
| Number of new technologies validated for the conditions of family agricultural production | Impact | Technologies | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.119 | |||||
| Total household net income | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en la población tratada | Impact | US$ | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.002 | Impact evaluation- PSM Treatment Group | |||
| Household Dietary Diversity Score, Weekly (0-12) | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en la población tratada | Impact | HDDS | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.001 | Impact evaluation- PSM Treatment Group | |||
| Household Dietary Diversity Score, Weekly (0-12) | Se reporta el promedio del grupo de control | Impact | HDDS | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | 0.022 | Impact evaluation-PSM Control group | |||
| Net farm income | Se reporta el efecto promedio del tratamiento en la población tratada | Impact | US$ | 19-07-2022 | 01-12-2018 | -0.343 | Impact evaluation- PSM Treatment Group | |||
| Households below the asset-based poverty line, 40th percentile | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.639 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Households below the asset-based poverty line, 60th percentile | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 90.224 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Income from the sale of natural resources from communal lands | Impact | USD | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 2.204 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Income from the sale of tree resources | Impact | USD | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 59.255 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Home Operated Parcels | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 45.52 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Households that started new businesses since 2011 | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 8.186 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Net profit from commercial activities | Impact | USD | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 1038.798 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Net income from crop sales | Impact | USD | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 1102.319 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Gini-Simpson index of crop diversification | Impact | Index | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 2.123 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Adult Food Insecurity Experience Scale Score | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.451 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Children Food Insecurity Experience Scale Score | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.26 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Household Dietary Diversity Score, Weekly | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.189 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Number of meals consumed per day by the household | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 35.521 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| New transportation system for the community from the baseline | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 56.158 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Households with activities selling products to final consumers | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 50.959 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Households with business activities selling products to merchants | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 3.033 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Households that buy seeds and other agricultural inputs from family and friends | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 1.403 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Women group in the community | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 1.780 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Existence of at least one group in the community | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.014 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Participation in farmer groups since 2011 (yes=1) | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.056 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Participation in women groups since 2011 (yes=1) | Impact | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 50.373 | Impact evaluation - control group | |||||
| Groups in which households participate since 2011 | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 686.504 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Households with members with leadership positions in farmer groups (%) | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.243 | Impact evaluation - control group | ||||
| Chakramamas families that cultivate at least 3 native species | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 1.786 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Increased coffee productivity | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.552 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Cocoa producers who sell at least 80% of their production through associative marketing structures | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 9.835 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Coffee producers who sell at least 80% of their production through associative marketing structures | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 2.635 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Participation of women as representatives | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 8.997 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Carrying out assemblies for the transmission and structured anchoring of strategic planning capacities | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 6.015 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Proposals or profiles of projects for local development prepared, prioritized and agreed upon jointly at the level of communities and associations | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 3.385 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Citizen participation events developed with the active presence of representatives of communities and associations | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 15.685 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Baseline of the project in the associative, productive agricultural and commercial spheres | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.223 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Support visits to delegates and leaders trained to replicate what they have learned in meetings and/or assemblies of their communities and associations | El cumplimiento del indicador se vio afectado por la emergencia sanitaria por COVID 19 | Impact | Number of communities | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.413 | Final external evaluation of the project | |||
| Participation in spaces for public advocacy and citizen participation to present community development proposals | Impact | number of spaces | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.013 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Participation of women in training in methods for ecological and sustainable cultivation of cocoa and coffee, in a participatory and practice-oriented manner | Impact | Percentage | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.011 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| Hectares rehabilitated for cocoa or coffee cultivation | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.077 | Final external evaluation of the project | ||||
| New hectares established for cocoa or coffee cultivation | Impact | Number | 05-08-2022 | 03-12-2018 | 0.813 | Final external evaluation of the project |
Sustentaibility
It measures the installed capacities or actions identified to maintain or improve the results of the policy initiative.
| Indicator | Description | Indicator Type | Measure Unit | Base date | Base | Goal | Measure Date | Measure | Compliance | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sustainability | 667,118 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 1,096,200 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 450,000 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 1,495,000 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 76,500 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 1,074,600 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 5,091,067 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 3,030,620 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 6,692,045 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 2,479,921 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 60,161,753 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 4,774,500 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 1,290,000 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 17,765,142 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 20,454,831 | |||||||||
| Sustainability | 7,233,104 |
Learned lessons
Gained knowledge from implementing, evaluating, and managing a policy intervention, including why it was or was not effective and how it could be improved in the future.
| Lesson | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|